Entry 32
This will be less of an adventure and more of a reflection but here goes...
I'm back on familiar ground and enjoying the vague sense of homecoming immensely. (I wonder if this is presient of my real home return soon to come.) Despite the filth, stench, decay, overcrowded and chaotic streets that are Mombasa, it's a city I know fairly well and enjoy spending time in. I spent an extra day there rather than returning straight to Diani Beach and thoroughly enjoyed the sights and sounds and smells (!) of this colourful island. Here one can watch fruit sellers hawking their mangos, pawpaws (papayas), coconuts and pineapples; elderly blind parents being led around by their seeing children seeking a few shillings from passersby; Muslim women covered from head to toe in their black bui buis--faces covered too but still sporting fashionable sunglasses; young men selling mobile phones, talk time, cheap watches and rubber stamps; shoeless, dusty street kids begging for food and/or money from tourists; Masai warriors in their red shukas and beaded belts from which their spears and knives and clubs dangle alongside their phones; and street vendors trying to make a sale of their clothes, stoves, pots and pans, flip flops or cheap plastic items. It's a hectic yet somehow attractive cacophony of sensorial experiences.
From Mombasa, I came back to Diani where my adventures started nearly 10 months ago. I returned to say goodbye to Colobus Trust and wish its various primates (of both the human and nonhuman variety) some fond farewells. I'm here to swim in the Indian Ocean for the last time. I'm here to watch the palm trees sway and smell the frangipani and other tropical flowers once more. I'm here to let the starry skies mesmorise once again. And I'm here to reflect on what I've learned, gained, and/or contributed. (Apparently I'm also here to watch some of the World Cup on large screen TV's too!)
I'll share with you some of my thoughts as I laid them down in my journal recently.
In his book Dark Star Safari--From Cairo to Capetown, Paul Theroux writes about revisiting Africa where he lived and taught in the 60's and hadn't been since, as well as the long road journey he makes from Egypt to South Africa. Reading his book while travelling along sections of the very same journey he writes about has been a delight; I've ridden some of the same buses, sat on some of the same matatus and slept on some of the same trains. Many critics have dismissed his writing for being too heavy and pessimistic. After having spent a bit of time on this continent and seeing a wee bit of what Africa is, I'm inclined to agree with many of his keen observations and carefully thought out evaluations of Africa and her struggles.
Theroux describes seeing many decrepit, run-down, virtually empty schools, with bare classrooms, unpaid staff, crumbling buildings and bookless libraries. This (among several other experiences) leads him to the epiphany that it is Africans themselves who must "fix" Africa. All the donor aid & volunteers, ngo's & charitable organizations, and the like have been working here for some 40 years or so to help change/stop the poverty, hunger, thirst, disease, illiteracy and other challenges that have plagued African countries for decades. Equipment gets sent over from well-intentioned people and breaks down and rusts by the sides of roads. This leaves villagers and townfolk now dependent on non-functioning technology. Skills are lost, training is stopped and unemployment rises. Another problem arises when projects get started, changing communities and ways of life, and then the funding dries up or the work has been deemed a success or the volunteers go home, so the project is ended, leaving communities and individuals often only slightly better off than before.
There have been several books written about how entire economies are based on aid money. They discuss how governments and many ngo's themselves (and the ubiquitous UN projects) actually benefit from keeping the poor, the hungry, and the sick dependent on donor systems.
As I traveled around Kenya, Tanzania, Malawi and Zambia, I saw first hand the benefits of water pumps brought into remote villages, community schools built for those too far/poor to attend regular schools, homes for orphans etc. Of course, these endeavors provide a better way of life, but how many people have I heard complain about how the money sent to staff those schools, maintain those water pumps and run those homes simply lines the pockets of corrupt officials and managers along the way? And for those organizations which manage to thwart corruption along the lines, how much money is lost to administrative, staffing and security costs?
It leaves me to wonder about the nature of charities, donations and volunteering in the "third world." I'm glad I chose to volunteer with projects initiated by Kenyans, but I'm not really sure if it was my money or my time and energy that was of greater import. And it makes me think that maybe the adages, "the lord provides for those who provide for themselves" and "give a man a fish and he'll eat for a day; teach a man to fish and he'll eat for a lifetime" need to be retaught. Not that many of the ngo's aren't already in the business of teaching Africans how to fend for themselves, but maybe Africans have to take the full initiative themselves. There's surely a place for western aid, but not along many of the avenues where it currently resides.
To reiterate Theroux, maybe all the western doctors and teachers and engineers and so on should just up and leave, and then we'll all see what happens. If the local communities want to continue the work started by these generous souls, so be it. That or let them burn the clinics and schools to the ground and plant maize and beans instead and at least reclaim the land it as their own. Even cash crops aren't being supported by local governments, making it unviable for growers to be anything other than subsistance farmers.
It seems that Africa has been forced to figure out in a few short decades what the west had over a century to do. Maybe she has to learn by her own mistakes as did we in the "developed" world. It's like many African countries are in their teen years, and we all know/remember that teens have to make their own decisions and learn how to stand on their own 2 feet. We can only provide guidance and support and hope for the best.
When I see people throwing their plastic bottles and food wrappings outside the bus windows as we speed past villages, farmland, bush and even national parks, I cringe every time. But isn't concern for the environment the privelege of us in the west who aren't living from hand to mouth and can take care of our surroundings as well as our families? I guess it's a choice that Kenyans, Tanzanians, Zambians and Malawians need to make for themselves. Why so many don't seem to give a hoot is hard to my Canadian eyes, but some have, and it's not for me to judge.
Anyway, these are just a few of my thoughts. Forgive my wandering wonderings. And please disagree.
In the remaining couple weeks I have left here, I shall have the pleasure of attending a traditional Masai wedding, revisiting the giraffe centre and elephant orphanage in Nairobi, seeing a few friends and saying goodbye, and returning to Kakamega to see the kids at the orphanage there once more. (Not to mention catching a few more World Cup matches.) Farewell readers and soccer/football fans.
